Skip to main content

China Killed “Good Enough.” Can India Do the Same?

Years ago, this blog documented the prevalence of the chabuduo mentality in China. The term, meaning "close enough" or "good enough," was, the post argued, an obstacle to China's further development, with both producers and consumers willing to tolerate imperfections. The resulting resignation that something cannot get better becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy, with mediocrity incentivized to exist, whether it be in the form of the half-baked products that break easily, improperly stored food that destroys stomachs, or questionable data that sow doubts in the research and statistical outputs.

It was just last week that I learned India has the same concept, with the equivalent Hindi term chalta hai. The argument against it mirrors exactly the Chinese discussion, with commentators blaming the mentality for everything from governmental dysfunction to the widespread acceptance of urban filth. Just as China had its share of unscrupulous businessmen and do-nothing officials during its era of speedy economic development, India's current bout of rapid growth is supposedly hampered by these individuals, making a quick buck by damaging their compatriots and the country's overall reputation.

Since I wrote about chabuduo in 2017, I'm curious to find that the term has become much less prevalent in the Chinese lexicon. Of course, the term is not yet obsolete, but no business dares to introduce its products and services brazenly with the term. Imperfect products exist, but the emphasis is now more on how the company can quickly collect customer feedback, systematically implement it in product development, and pump out the next, improved version that could garner praise from those same complaining customers. Chabuduo is no longer an end condition, but the beginning of a process.

Surely, if chabuduo is culturally ingrained, the mentality could not possibly disappear after a few years. What changed was the business environment. The hypercompetitive economic environment in China not only pushed many of its businesses abroad. It also pushed consumers to be discerning because now they have a large number of choices, each of which is doing its best to stand out from an increasingly crowded field by demonstrating how good their products and services are compared to what rivals can offer. 

At the same time, the internet has made judgment of good and bad almost instantaneous, universal, and permanent. Any mistake a business makes with a customer could quickly be viewed by millions. Any small negative word-of-mouth becomes a stain large enough to ensure future customers go elsewhere. With so many choices available, no one needs to be brand-loyal or forgive mistakes. That brutal reality forces every company to perfect everything, because the continued existence of the company depends on it. 

The resulting death of chabuduo in China's public sphere has lessons for India and anywhere else that struggles with the prevalence of "good enough." Commentators talk about the need for meritocracy, with the few exceptions in a sea of mediocrity intentionally elevated to lead companies and countries. But in all honesty, people want to cut corners because often that's efficient, profitable, and easy. Laziness makes business and logical sense if the customers are accepting. So rather than changing the providers, the goal ought to be empowering the consumers.

China's path away from chabuduo shows that increased competition and widespread transparency in reputation are the ways forward. Customers can punish chabuduo by walking away, complaining online, and making sure the negative experiences are heard and heeded widely. Businesses will no longer be content with "good enough" when they start to fear the consumer and their ability to punish any lapses in quality. If a company constantly think their survival is at stake, there's no way that they'd be okay with chalta hai.

And as competition becomes entrenched, the best of any country comes out on top and becomes the highlight. Both the Chinese and the Indians suffer from persistent negative stereotypes that question their basic abilities to adhere to civic values and maintain reasonably comfortable, clean standards of living. Given that each individual has their own subjective definition of what is "good," these stereotypes are unfair, to say the least. But when those few who aren't content with "good enough" become successful, the whole country's image will inevitably change. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sexualization of Japanese School Uniform: Beauty in the Eyes of the Holders or the Beholders?

The Japanese female high school uniform is almost a cultural institution in itself.  Immortalized in anime such as “Sailor Moon” and countless bittersweet love stories of campus romance on the big and small screens, its distinctive blue-and-white sailor-like design is recognizable to even the most casual purveyors of Japanese culture.  For millions in Japan, it is the visual manifestation of what it means to be youthful, innocent, and full of hope and drama.  It is the physical reminder of the coming of age.

Asian Men Are Less "Manly"?!

ok, this isn't a new topic...plenty of people have written about the fact that Asian men are perceived as comparatively not masculine in popular culture (not just here in the USA, but also in Asia itself). White male models are used for underwear advertising, black males are used for adult videos (ok, maybe that one is just biological...but still), and as everyone knows, interracial couples with Asian females are much much more common than with Asian males (and because of that, Asian guys who get non-Asian girls, especially white ones, gains incredible respect from his Asian male friends as long as the girl is not too ugly).

Instigator and Facilitator: the Emotional Distraught of a Mid-Level Manager

Among the intellectuals of the world, there has long been a consensus on the defining quality of individual success.  It is not measured by the amount of cash in one's bank account, the net worth of one's business, assets, and properties.  Instead, the key word is "power," the authority one has over other individuals and functioning of a community, and to a greater extent, society in general.  The ability to influence and to change the course of other's lives, in particular, can be seen an easy, albeit morally reprehensible, way to get one's hands on an almost unlimited flow of cash.